I have a general rule that when I choose Oscar Best Picture mistakes, I only choose from the nominees. I am ignoring that rule today. Here are the films that I think should have won Best Picture. Nominee or not.
1950-All About Eve
1964-Dr. Strangelove: Or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb. My Fair Lady was a decent film. But almost everything it won it robbed from this film.
There you have it, the films that I agree with winning, or should have won, Best Picture. Please let me know what you think!